Our epic interview with legendary action movie specialist Sam Firstenberg concludes with Part 2. Mr. Firstenberg discusses
his varied film career from 1985 to 2003--covering his remaining Cannon works, post-Cannon, Nu Image--and what he's doing
today. I would like to extend an immense thanks to Mr. Firstenberg for donating so much of his personal time for this interview.
There are links at the bottom to his website, and to the kickstarter for a 600+ page book about his entire career, and many
of those who worked at Cannon.
Venoms5: We're at AMERICAN NINJA (1985). Do you recall if, prior to Michael Dudikoff being selected, there was anyone
who came in to read for the part of Joe Armstrong that was already a big name or became an established name later?
Sam Firstenberg: This was an open-call. Anyone could come. Some of the casting sessions are only through agents. This
one we decided to do an open-call. We sent messages to martial arts schools, acting schools, agents... many, many people came
for the part. We saw anywhere between 300-500 people. Mike Norris came and I made a movie with him later on, DELTA FORCE 3
(1991); and Chad McQueen who had a career later. Those are the two that I remember.
V5: What was the working relationship like with Yamashita compared with Sho Kosugi?
SF: Both of them are masters of their arts. Tadashi was a little more established because he had done THE OCTAGON (1980)
and had been making movies a bit longer. Both men had their own students and both had their own aura of being a leader and
the ego that goes along with it. Sho Kosugi was a very flamboyant character. He showed off more with the big aspirations to
be a movie star. Tadashi was more humble, stuck to the principals of how a martial arts fighter is with the quietness and
self-discipline. I am still in contact with Tadashi. We call each other just to talk. He would help in any way on the set.
It was a real pleasure to work with him.
We had many martial artists working on the set of this movie. Mike Stone was the choreographer; Tadashi was on the set;
Richard Norton, an accomplished martial artist, he was on the set; Steve Lambert and Steve James were martial artists... so
there was a lot of martial arts camaraderie on the set. They all respected each other.
V5: For AMERICAN NINJA, there was something very special about this production. Compared with your other action films,
the atmosphere is more family-friendly. Was this the intention from the beginning?
SF: We talked about the party atmosphere on BREAKIN' 2--the atmosphere on AMERICAN NINJA was even more jubilant! In the
beginning Michael Dudikoff worked with Mike Stone for two weeks preparing him for the fight scenes. Immediately upon seeing
the first dallies we knew we had something special with two strong leads in Michael and Steve James. On the first day you
could see it. Those two guys were charismatic. They both had a great amount of movie star appeal. Plus, it was so cheap to
shoot in the Philippines there was no limit for the budget. We
could accomplish any crazy idea that came to mind. The Filipino crew were all very capable. We had anything we needed.
Whoever had an idea we could accomplish it... try to do it, at least. There was no pressure for schedule since we had three
big units working together... it was pretty luxurious. There was this feeling immediately that something big was happening.
We all stayed in the same hotel--the entire cast and crew. So we were shooting together, eating together, on Sunday going
to the pool together... we all had a fabulous time. There was a camaraderie between us all. It was hard work, too. It was
very hot in the Philippines; over a hundred degrees everyday, 110-115 degrees. Michael Duthie was editing back in LA and we
saw the sequences and they all looked good so we felt the magic.
I directed 25 movies. None of them compare to the popularity of AMERICAN NINJA (1985). People still talk about it today.
Young people see it and enjoy it; it's really a phenomenon for a low budget movie. Sometimes I think about what makes this
film different from others. Once in a while there are movies that, for whatever reason, clicks with people. ROCKY (1976) ,
for example; it was only a one million budget but it became a classic. Nobody believed in it in the beginning and it became
huge. Another example is CASABLANCA (1942). It was a low budget movie. The director, Joe Cortez, was a 'B' movie director.
He did Tarzan movies. The entire film was shot in a studio, but the magic was there.
We can be a little bit humble and say AMERICAN NINJA is not in the same league as those (laughs), but number one, it's
the actors. There is a chemistry between them. And then, AMERICAN NINJA is a very innocent movie. It's very much like a western
with its reluctant hero. His values compel him to act just like Gary Cooper in HIGH NOON (1952), I'd say. He doesn't want
to fight anybody but the circumstances and his moral values compel him to become part of the action. So this is a good type
of hero that people easily identify with. Michael had this James Dean face that feeds this type of hero. Then, there are two
love stories. There is a romantic story between Michael and Judi's characters; and there is the strong friendship between
Michael and Steve James. So those are universal values. It's not all about action. All of those people are very innocent looking,
young, handsome, they have charisma on the screen... you add to this the character of Tadashi Yamashita the villain and Don
Stewart as Ortega and beautiful scenery; we tried to get the most beautiful places in the Philippines on the screen, so the
magic works. The stars aligned with this movie.
V5: Why do you think Michael Dudikoff never became the next big action star like Stallone, or Norris, or Bronson?
SF: In my opinion it's only technical. It had to do with the movement in Hollywood. Sometimes a person can jump into stardom
but more often it takes a lot of coordination to become a big star. What I mean by that is a lot of public relations, advertising,
and doing the gossip magazines. The big studios had the time, the money, and the knowledge to create a star; you know, to
make sure he or she goes to the right parties, has the right escort, etc, etc; so there is a lot of work involved in making
a star. I think Cannon didn't have the knowledge and the resources to do the same with Michael. This is my speculation, of
course. They just employed him in one movie after the other without investing in the PR machine for him. At some point they
became very busy with Chuck Norris. He was exclusively contracted to Cannon at that time. Despite the fact they made 200 to
300 movies they didn't have big hits; not even the Superman they made was a big hit. They had a decent success with THE DELTA
FORCE (1986), the two BREAKIN's, and the two AMERICAN NINJAs. And a little bit with Bronson and the DEATH WISH movies.
V5: Did you ever meet Norris or Charles Bronson while at Cannon?
SF: Yes, I met both of them. Bronson I only met on the set. I went to visit J. Lee Thompson and they were shooting outside
on location. I was introduced to Bronson. He was a very quiet, private man, He was in his RV, comes out to shoot, then goes
back to his caravan. He was not socializing... he was not that type of person. He was reclusive. He didn't talk with anyone
except for the director. I don't remember the film he was making.
Now Chuck Norris, I was supposed to make a movie with him. I was supposed to do MISSING IN ACTION III (1988). I met with
him a few times to discuss the picture, but it didn't happen. He was busy with something else. My wife became pregnant; they
moved me to another movie and eventually Aaron Norris directed that film. I would see him on occasion in the corridors at
Cannon. I would see virtually everyone there from Chuck Norris to Tobe Hooper to Joseph Zito... but not Charles Bronson.
V5: AVENGING FORCE (1986) was originally a Chuck Norris picture. Do you recall why Norris didn't do the film?
SF: We were making AMERICAN NINJA and Norris was making INVASION USA (1985) with Joseph Zito at the same time. Norris
was more established than Michael was so they were looking for another project for Norris. James Booth, the actor, had this
script called 'Night Hunter' that was fitted for Chuck Norris. It was offered to him but I am not sure what happened as I
was not there. I was doing the sound mix for AMERICAN NINJA and Menahem Golan came to me and asked me to read this script
and decide if it was good enough for Michael and Steve James. The script blew my mind. I'd never read a script like this before.
It was perfect for them. There was only one thing that was changed. In the script Matt Hunter had a daughter; it was a father-daughter
story. Michael was too young to have a daughter so we changed it to a sister. We had just finished AMERICAN NINJA and two
weeks later we were preparing to do AVENGING FORCE. It was a much better script and didn't have any of the innocence of AMERICAN
NINJA but the script was tight, the dialog was strong, the action was good... James Booth put together a good script. Cannon
tried to persuade us not to shoot in New Orleans because it is an expensive city but it was written for New Orleans. They
eventually gave in and told us to go and make the movie.
V5: Do you have a story of working with James Booth? He had just worked with Sho on PRAY FOR DEATH (1985)--a film he also
SF: When I started to work on pre-production for AVENGING FORCE (1986), I worked with James on some things but we became
really good friends. He was a very nice man, a gentleman. He had just worked at Trans World; he was trying to get me a job
there. As I said before there was a rivalry between them so Cannon hired Jim. He was so helpful on the set. It was a luxury
to have a writer like him on the set. Of course, he also played a part in the movie. He went back to Britain but every time
he came to Los Angeles he would come to my house. He did this until he died. We made a few more movies together. We went to
South Africa to make AMERICAN NINJA 2: THE CONFRONTATION (1987). We tried to put other projects together but they never materialized.
V5: Steve James had an enormous screen presence. He seemed to throw himself into his action roles. He died far too young.
Do you have some stories of working with him you possibly haven't told before whether film-related or otherwise?
SF: What he had in mind was to be the next big black action hero. He was a martial artist with this tremendous body. He
kept in shape all the time. He wanted to be the next John Shaft. He was working on it and he was on his way. We became very
good friends on AMERICAN NINJA. Now on AVENGING FORCE he hated the idea that he had to die in that movie (laughs). He told
me, "Sam, Steve James is not in the movie business to die; I want to be a hero, not somebody who dies." But the
part was too good for him to reject. I told him, "Steve, you are advancing your career; you'll have many more parts so
don't worry." Everything Steve did he did it with 100% of his heart. Before we started work on AMERICAN NINJA 2, he went
Israel to make THE DELTA FORCE (1986) for Menahem Golan. While he was there he met an Isaeli woman and fell in love...
Nava was her name. When we went to South Africa to shoot the second AMERICAN NINJA Steve was concerned because it was an apartheid
state, but it was coming to an end. He would call me and ask if I thought it was safe for him to come there. So when he came,
AMERICAN NINJA had already played in South Africa. It was a big hit. So you couldn't walk with him in the streets in South
Africa. People were swarming around him. They saw a hero in Steve James. So when I walked with him to the market or shopping
he was always surrounded by admirers.
Anyway, he brought Nava down there; she has a little part in the movie. After we finished Steve went back to Israel and
he and Nava got married and came back to LA. I stayed in touch with them for a long time and we made RIVERBEND (1989). Steve
was ecstatic because this was his movie. He wasn't playing second fiddle to somebody else. He was the star. We filmed that
in Texas. We didn't get to work together again after that. He got divorced and married somebody else so by that point our
contact was dwindling. Then he got sick. Somebody told me Steve was very sick. I wanted to go and visit him but he wouldn't
accept guests because he didn't look as robust as he wanted to look.
What I'm about to tell you is part of the story but when we were shooting AMERICAN NINJA Steve figures into the final
scene. He came to me and said, "I want to rip off my shirt and throw it away (laughs)". I ask him why and he tells
me "I am not working this hard for this body for nothing. I want people to see this body (laughs)!" And he did it
again in AVENGING FORCE and in the second AMERICAN NINJA. He did it in RIVERBEND, too! So to go back to when he was sick with
cancer, he didn't look good and he didn't want guests to come and see him. I never saw him again. I went to the funeral and
talked to his father. It was too bad. He was a rising star. Now I am in contact with his daughter from his first marriage--Debi
James. She is running a campaign to try and get him a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. She has a Facebook page called 'My
Dad Steve James'.
V5: Cannon tends to get a lot of flack in Hollywood, but they were unafraid to give people chances. What would you say
was Cannon's greatest strengths and their greatest weaknesses?
SF: The people who ran Cannon were outsiders. Hollywood operated under rules that had been established through the years.
The studios were very powerful. A lot of money is running through Hollywood. It is bigger than just making movies; it is about
the glitz, the fame, the parties.... It is a big machine that feeds itself with certain rules. The heads of the studios and
agencies are very powerful people with big money exchanging hands. Then there are the independent companies not part of the
big machine like Roger Corman, Carolco, Coppola's Zoetrope company and Cannon. The other people I mentioned tried to emulate
Hollywood and wanted to become part of it. Steven Spielberg makes Amblin to be a part of Hollywood, not to fight it or be
different from it. Those two guys--Menahem Golan and Yoram Globus--they wanted to defy the establishment. They wanted to do
things their way; no big parties, no big lunches, no golf clubs or flying all over the world; yachts and spending tons of
money entertaining the stars, etc. Instead they invested all their energy, resources and money into making movies; and taking
chances along the way.
If they saw somebody, like say John Cassavetes, who wanted to make a movie and the establishment wouldn't give him a chance,
then Cannon would reach out to him and make him an offer. So they took a lot of chances while spending all their time making
movies. This is part of their strength; but because they were making so many films they didn't have the time or patience for
quality control. They didn't have the best movies or the most successful ones. Adding to that they started to irritate the
Hollywood establishment which eventually led to their demise. They weren't careful with money, spending more than they made.
On the other hand, they had a lot of product. They loved making movies. They tried to get into other areas of exhibition,
theaters, and distribution but were unsuccessful. Still, they left behind a legacy with a big library of movies with a specific
look; some people call it 'The Cannon Look'--low budget with an international appeal. This was Cannon in a nutshell.
V5: How did you meet David Bradley? You did a few movies with him after the Cannon period.
SF: When Cannon came to an end it was a bankruptcy case. There was a split between Menahem and Yoram. Menahem took some
of the money, some of the scripts, and some of the developmental properties and created his own company called 21st Century.
Yoram Globus with Giancarlo Parretti took some of the remaining properties and created another Cannon which was run by Christopher
Pearce. MGM got most of the library because Cannon owed a lot of money to them. All the movies I directed ended up with MGM.
So I got a call from the new Cannon. They owned the rights to THE DELTA FORCE (1986) and they wanted to make a part three.
They decided to shoot it in Israel since Yoram Globus had studios there and it would be cheaper to do so. I was already in
Israel making an Israeli comedy and had just finished the film. The same story from before happened again. They had a director
from Australia who wasn't working out for whatever reason. After two or three days they stopped and turned to me and asked
me to start over on the picture. The budget was bigger than my other movies. It was a big military movie. They sold it to
So I am back in Los Angeles doing the editing on DELTA FORCE 3 (1991) and they call me to the offices and tell me they
want to make another ninja movie. They had a guy named David Bradley already lined up to star. I didn't know him at that time.
I agreed to do the film even though we had no clear idea what it was supposed to be. They wanted to use the AMERICAN NINJA
title but they couldn't since the property belonged to MGM so it became AMERICAN SAMURAI (1992). I was introduced to David
Bradley and we began preparing the movie and shot it in Israel.
V5: Can you describe what happened with AMERICAN SAMURAI? Did the production run out of money or did someone get injured?
During the last fight there are a lot of closeups and quick cuts of blades clashing that don't always match the ones David
and Mark Dacascos are holding.
SF: AMERICAN SAMURAI was a bad experience for me. When we began shooting in Israel the script was changed so we began
changing what we were doing. We finished and edited it in Israel with an Israeli editor. Meantime I had gotten another job
directing a TV series in Israel called SWEATING BULLETS... for ABC, I believe. It was kind of a detective series shooting
over there. Every second episode I directed. So on the week I wasn't working on the TV show I was working on AMERICAN SAMURAI
with the editor. We finished it and sent it back to Los Angeles. At that point they formed a partnership with some famous
producer named Jere Henshaw. Apparently, and unknown to me, this producer decided to bring in another editor to re-edit the
movie without my knowledge. They also shot some additional scenes like the love scene between David and the woman. The fight
we had for David and Mark didn't originally have a lot of choreography. There had been so many fights in the arena we decided
to go for a traditional style samurai fight where the kill would be a single blow; like a showdown in a western. This producer
who was put in charge didn't like it so he had the other editor create a fight from nothing.
V5: This is probably your goriest movie. There's an incredible amount of bloody violence in it. Unfortunately, the version
that was released on tape was severely edited, but it was uncut on cable.
SF: That's what we were going for in this movie--it being in an arena with a lot of ugly characters so the goriness suited
this atmosphere. Someone wrote to me recently about this movie; a guy who said his dad showed it to him when he was four years
old and he remembered it (laughs).
V5: The two CYBORG COP films you made are a lot of fun. Were these pleasant experiences for you?
SF: Yes. I made them after the new Cannon went out of business. They only made two movies--DELTA FORCE 3 and AMERICAN
SAMURAI and that was it. By then, the company that became Nu Image was a South African company that was called Nu Metro. I
used them because they were providing us the services when we did AMERICAN NINJA 2 (1987). It was being run by Avi Lerner,
Danny Dimbort and Trevor Shaw. It was mainly a theater company but they provided services for movie productions too. I knew
them and Danny Dimbort was part of Cannon anyways. When the apartheid was over and Mandela took power with the National Congress
I guess they were afraid the country would turn Communist and they sold the theater chain. They had a lot of money. One day
I met one of the owners in LA and he told me they were switching from theaters to producing movies. The first one they want
to make is 'American Ninja Cyborg', or something like that. They didn't have a script or an idea or anything of what it was
supposed to be. The only things they knew was that they wanted me to direct it and for David Bradley to star. I agreed. We
wrote a script with a South African writer and Boaz Davidson came along as the producer. So myself and Greg Latter the writer
came up with some ideas for what would be my first time doing science fiction; or SciFi-Action. We hired a British company
to make all the prosthetics.
For distribution purposes, I didn't want to make a film that was about South Africa so, while we shot there, we gave the
impression it took place in a tropical setting like Jamaica. The story was kind of similar to what we did in AMERICAN NINJA
2. We had a mad scientist creating cyborgs so you can't take something like this too seriously (laughs). We went for a lighter
tone with the exotic setting, the music, and we were all conscious of this while writing the script. We sold it immediately,
too. New Line Cinema bought it. For the sequel we went back to South Africa but this time, the setting was supposed to be
America. We kept the same tongue-in-cheek tone as well. Plus, as our villain in the first movie we had John Rhys-Davies. You
cannot have a serious movie with John Rhys-Davies (see insert).
V5: I take it you had a good time working with him?
SF: Oh, he was fantastic. What an actor. He was the traditional British actor. He came to me on the first day--we stayed
in the same hotel in Johannesburg--and he says to me he is an actor's actor... "I'll do whatever you ask me to do. If
you don't like my take I'll do it however you want. I'll do it exactly the way you tell me. For me it's a profession."
That's how he was. He helped out with his character too, coming up with ideas. He had just done INDIANA JONES AND THE LAST
V5: David Bradley took over as the American Ninja in part three and co-starred with Michael Dudikoff, who returned as
Joe in part 4. Was it true there was some animosity between the two of them working on that picture?
SF: That's what I understand but I wasn't there. At the time Cannon decided to carry on the series but doing it much cheaper.
Basically to ride the wave of the first two movies but with very low budgets. I think Michael didn't want to do part three
because he wanted to try other roles and different ideas. He didn't want to be identified only as the American Ninja. So they
made these other films in South Africa with a South African director and crew. When they came to part four they somehow convinced
Michael to do it. I think Michael and David knew each other before they did the movie. David was a car salesman and that's
how they met. Michael came to him to buy a car and Michael brought him to Cannon; but that is before what I am telling you.
I'm not 100% sure what happened with them. David disappeared. He is in Texas teaching martial arts somewhere but nobody knows
where he is. I tried to contact him but there is no response. I had a good relationship with him and I cannot find him. The
guy who is writing the book now about my movies, 'Stories From the Trenches', tried very hard to find David but couldn't.
V5: Did you enjoy shooting in South Africa compared to either the Philippines or the United States?
SF: I love Africa. But the expertise of filmmaking was not there. I told you when we went to the Philippines they had
really good crews there. Whatever they didn't have you just had to cross the water to Hong Kong; just a one hour flight. You
had highly skilled technicians either from the Filipino's or from Hong Kong. In South Africa it was like the end of the world.
Their only experience was with commercials or television. They had little experience with making movies. When Cannon came
in it was the first real moviemaking they had there. So from a professional point of view it was not as good as the Philippines.
Later on I also worked in Indonesia and it was same experience as South Africa. The best places to work from a technical perspective
are Hollywood, Great Britain and Israel. Israel had a lot of film expertise. A lot of big movies were shot there like JESUS
CHRIST SUPERSTAR (1973), RAMBO III (1988), big, big movies. But I love Africa. The people there were very nice. I love the
animals. But it is very hard to work there; no equipment and few people with experience. For example, when we shot AMERICAN
NINJA 2 (1987) we brought a lot of people from here, while the two CYBORG COP movies were all done with local labor who were
more accustomed to working on three day schedules doing commercials versus a nine week shoot on a movie set; six days a week
and 12 hours a day.
V5: You showed a real knack for doing horror as well. You worked with Tobe Hooper on CROCODILE (2001) and directing SPIDERS
2: BREEDING GROUND (2001).
SF: Horror movies, like these slashers and things, it's a lot like doing comedy; you have to like it. I did not grow up
with these kinds of movies. Americans grew up with horror pictures. It is part of the American culture. In Israel it is a
tough society with the military, and many people participating in war; so we laugh at horror movies. They are not scared of
them. It is a different culture. I never saw a horror movie in my life till THE EXORCIST (1973). I was a student here in Los
Angeles. Somebody said, "Let's go see this movie", and we went to see it. Now, there are horror movies that are
also science fiction like ALIEN (1979) and I really liked that one a lot. It was horror created through a lot of tension,
which I prefer as opposed to the horror of the slasher variety. When I was offered to do the sequel to SPIDERS (2000) I saw
an opportunity to do a SciFi movie with horror together. I was trying create an atmosphere along the lines of ALIEN (1979).
Instead of a spaceship you're on a ship at sea... you don't see the creature till halfway through, and I enjoyed this a lot.
This kind of horror isn't in the sense of killing young women.
V5: This was for Nu Image as well, yes?
SF: Yes. Nu Image moved from South Africa to make movies here. They used the same formula as Cannon, but many of them
came from Cannon already. Boaz Davidson, Danny Dimbort, Avi Lerner... they started to make a lot of movies only Nu Image is
a privately owned company as opposed to a public company. I made the two CYBORG COP pictures for them, THE ALTERNATE (2000)
with Eric Roberts, and OPERATION: DELTA FORCE (1997) so I was doing the same sort of films I had done for Cannon. The difference
is that in Cannon it was bigger and Nu Image was a smaller company but they have grown into a company that makes big movies
V5: Do you recall the first time you met Tobe Hooper? You mentioned POLTERGEIST being influential on NINJA III.
SF: I first met him in the corridors of the Cannon Films office building. There were many editing rooms back there and
if I am not mistaken, he was working with his editor in one while I was working with my editor in another; so we bumped into
each other on occasion. Small talk led to mutual appreciation. Of course, he was already famous for TEXAS CHAINSAW and POLTERGEIST.
Years later we both worked for Nu Image and at one point they needed me to join Tobe on CROCODILE (2001) as a 2nd unit director
to handle some of the action sequences. I was more than thrilled to lend a hand in conjunction with Tobe. A year later I was
invited to a horror film festival where he was given a Lifetime Achievement Award. He could not be there in person so I accepted
it for him and gave an acceptance speech.
V5: You said earlier you weren't much of a horror fan but did you see TEXAS CHAINSAW? If so what did you think of it?
SF: I did see it. But like I said before, living in Israel I didn't grow up with these kinds of movies. I didn't find
it scary but rather campy and even funny in places.
V5: When you were making SPIDERS 2 (2001) did you find it problematic at all working with the giant spider as opposed
to a lot of CGI which was very popular for those types of films at the time?
SF: Working with that giant mechanical puppet spider came right after I did 2nd unit on CROCODILE. I worked with a mechanical
crocodile on that one so I already had some experience in doing so. It was a challenge at times but this is the type of professional
challenge that I welcome because it breeds new ideas and allows me to come up with new cinematic solutions; the type of tasks
I enjoy conquering. We had some CG shots too, so I had that to deal with as well.
V5: If there was one movie you could change or not do at all what would it be and why?
SF: McCINSEY'S ISLAND (1998), with Robert Vaughn and Hulk Hogan. It was all done hastily. When I got involved it was only
half a script. They had a writer but all the way through it was unclear what sort of movie we were making. There were a few
different entities involved and they all saw the movie in a different light. For instance the distribution company wanted
us to make a straight action picture. The production company wanted to do a children's comedy film. The direction we were
going was unclear the entire time. The main force was Hulk Hogan; the deal hinged on him. He wanted to shoot the movie in
Florida so he could be close to his home; so the whole production moved next to his house because he didn't want to travel.
Actually, despite it all, it was a lot of fun making the movie. Working in Florida was very nice. Hulk Hogan was fantastic
to work with. A very nice man. Everyday he was on set hundreds of his fans came to watch him work. Children would come to
get his autograph. So we had a good time, but the script was developing as we were going; when we started the script was not
finished. We were trying to salvage it all the time, trying to figure out what to do. Hulk Hogan appeals to kids so we wanted
to keep it for kids; then we were pressured to make it an action picture... then suddenly Grace Jones is added to the movie.
She was not part of the cast when we started (laughs). There was too many factors conflicting with each other. I don't feel
I did a good job on it. I can live without it but sometimes people ask me--very seldom--about this movie so it has its own
Now the strangest movie I ever made was NINJA III: THE DOMINATION (1984). It's the most bizarre, crazy movie but it has
a lot of fans and I can't understand it. I am very surprised by how many people write to me about this movie... and they love
it! Somebody just wrote me saying it was their favorite movie; and I'm like, "Are you for real?" (laughs).
V5: So were you satisfied with your work on NINJA III?
SF: It's a mixture of too many genres. There's horror, exorcism, action, martial arts, dancing... too many things together
for a 95 minute movie. But it became a cult classic. A guy called me from England about this festival, 'The Best Worst Movies
in the World'. One of the selections is NINJA III: THE DOMINATION. I was at a film festival in Madrid called CutreCon and
it featured NINJA III: THE DOMINATION. I got a call to appear at a festival in Holland in June, the International Cult Film
Festival, and they are showing.... NINJA III: THE DOMINATION (laughs)! So this movie started something. As a ninja movie it
was not successful. Sho Kosugi was right. The audience was not willing to accept a ninja heroine. From a box office point
of view, both REVENGE OF THE NINJA and AMERICAN NINJA enjoyed much better box office. The audience for these movies is young
men... that's it. Women don't go to see ninja or martial arts movies. There are exceptions, of course. So this movie wasn't
accepted at first but years later it is embraced by the cult audience (laughs)!
V5: What is your opinion of action films made today compared to when you were making them?
SF: There is a big shift in action. The genre today caters to kids who grew up with video games. Their mental interpretation
of what action is comes from the video games they play. In a video game, the action is moving very fast. The editing in these
games is also very fast. Modern action movies are all about fast cutting and a fast pace with action that defies reality...
which is spectacular. This is what the young audience expects. So what you get with Spiderman and Superman is action that
is not real. Even when you see something like THE FAST AND THE FURIOUS (2001), you're seeing cars that can fly like an airplane
between two buildings. With the use of computer graphics, you can do whatever you want today. There is no limit anymore. When
we made action movies, and had limited budgets, the action had to be performed physically. Either the actor or his stunt double
would perform the action for real. Two people would stand in front of each other and have a fight. If somebody fell from the
top floor of a building to the ground, somebody did it. Therefore we didn't need fast cutting. We could stay on the actors
with a long shot and show the action. You mentioned earlier the van chase from REVENGE OF THE NINJA... we had Sho Kosugi flying
through the glass from the roof of the car. We had to do it physically. We had no electronic means to do it.
Nowadays you would have Matt Damon fly through the glass and he wouldn't do anything because he's standing in front of
a blue screen with cables, and the cables would lift him; and later on it would be altered digitally. I believe that you can
sense it. In modern action sequences you know the actor is not there. There are lots of inserts and cuts that give the impression
that a fight is taking place. The action today is much more spectacular than what we did. We couldn't have done these things
back then. Cinematically, it's breathtaking but it lacks the punch--you don't feel the pain. When we would jump a car or motorcycle
it was done for real. This is painful. You can feel it on the landing. Today it's slow motion and flying, flying, flying with
a soft landing... you can tell it's computerized. You get less involved in these action sequences.
The medium budgeted action pictures have disappeared. So now you have the big event movies--150 million to 200 million
budget; or for economical reasons, you have a very low budget where you cannot possibly deliver on the action. You can't create
45 minutes of action on a one million budget. You can see in the action movies Nu Image is making or the ones Isaac Florentine
is directing in five weeks. It's a pity as it's impossible to produce enough action in five weeks. This is the economic reality
of movies these days. They come either very cheap or very expensive. That is what is happening in the world of action today
V5: It's like these pictures today are all special effects with less attention paid to the characters.
SF: I used to always maintain that each action sequence would tell a little story. A beginning, a middle, and an end--even
within the action sequence. I would discuss this with the action and stunt coordinators. I would ask them what is the beginning
and the conclusion of your fight; give me a little story. They would show me and sometimes I would encourage them to change
some things; like we couldn't have the hero winning all the time; there would need to be obstacles to overcome... the action
sequences would be a little story by itself.
V5: What are you doing today? Do you have any projects you're working on now?
SF: The only projects I am working on now is building furniture. I haven't directed a movie in many years now. The last
thing I directed was a SciFi parody called THE INTERPLANETARY SURPLUS MALE AND AMAZON WOMEN OF OUTER SPACE (2003). I have
no film projects coming my way because the type of movies I was known for aren't made anymore--with this type of budget. Back
then we made those movies for like 5 million dollars which would take 15 of 20 million today and these aren't being made.
I was part of the Hollywood establishment and I was branded as a director of medium budget movies as opposed to big pictures
or very low cost ones. So basically I am out of the directing business. I have a very beautiful hobby of designing and building
V5: If someone were to approach you about directing again would you do it?
SF: I would do it, but I would not do it with a low budget as you cannot deliver. I don't want to break my rule of 45
minutes of good action. But in reality I would do a low budget movie but on a different subject--something more dramatic like
a love story. I love all kinds of movies although I am not crazy about horror. If it were a big budget action-adventure, then
yes, I would do it. But at 67 years old I would much rather do a movie about relationships, a social drama, something like
that. I have done a lot of action already. But I've done a bit of everything. I've done musicals, comedies, SciFi, horror...
so I'd like to go back to where I started and do a social drama like ONE MORE CHANCE (1983) a film with social relevance.
V5: What advice would you give any young filmmaker wishing to become a film director?
SF: Today it is very simple to make a movie. All you need is a camera and a computer and a few lights. Cameras are cheap.
You can buy a 4K camera for $2,000. They are so sensitive to light you need some lights and you can rent those. You can do
your editing on your computer. So for $4-$5,000 you have your own studio. Get yourself a good group of people. Then, you're
a young director who wants to showcase what you can do. Of course, don't try to make some big action movie unless you get
the chance. Robert Rodriguez said something like, "If you decide you are a director then you are a director, but what
are the means around you that you can use to showcase your talent?" If you have an uncle who is a butcher, you make a
movie about a butcher and shoot for free in your uncle's shop. You're a storyteller... you don't have to make Indiana Jones
to prove that you are talented. Get together with a writer and together one of you writes and the other directs. Physically,
it's easy to make a movie today. And you don't need to live in a big city, either. You don't need a lab for sound mix; you
can do it at home. You shoot, you load to your computer, you begin editing, you can correct color by yourself.... It's limitless.
Exhibition today is unbelievable too; the streaming, all the different websites like Vimeo. You don't need distribution. When
we made movies we had the big camera, the lab work, we needed a distribution company... this took a lot of money just to put
the movie together. It was like a war sometimes. That's why the new book from Marco is called 'Stories From the Trenches'
because making every movie was like a battle. Today it's easier; you only have to prove you understand the cinematic language
to tell your story in a compelling way. Good storytelling is key no matter the means with which you realize it.
V5: Before we wrap up this interview, Mr. Firstenberg, I must tell you that when I was a kid whenever I would be in a
video store, or if I was watching cable television, and one of your movies came on, as soon I saw your name in the credits
I would say to myself, "I have gotta watch this".
SF: (laughs) You know, Sam is not my real name. My name is Samuel and the biblical pronunciation of my name in Hebrew
is Shmuel or Shmulik. It was Cannon that decided my name to make it sell.... to make it sound like a Hollywood name (laughs).
Listen, I want to say one last thing. Those movies I directed were violent. But those movies have a feeling of a fairy tale...
tongue in cheek. You have this feeling that it's not taken seriously. There are some movies that are too real. Like the Clint
Eastwood movie, AMERICAN SNIPER (2014). There is no kidding around, no fairy tale feeling in this movie. The action is so
real. I was shocked. When I left the theater I was shaking. And this is the difference. The action and violence in my movies
is not for real. They have a resilience through the years that appeals to a younger audience. You will not show AMERICAN SNIPER
to a seven year old but you can show them AMERICAN NINJA.
And speaking of that film, I'll tell you one last story for a conclusion. When I was in Spain last January at the CutreCon
International Film Festival, people were bringing books, posters, movies for me to sign; before the screening there was a
Q&A; after the screening they'd come again with a few more things to sign, take pictures... and one day--I told you they
screened NINJA III--a young woman comes up to me with a big original poster for AMERICAN NINJA (1985). By now it's rare, it's
the one with the flag on it. Most people have these small posters or photos and she has this huge poster. She opens it up
and asks me to sign it. I gladly signed it for her but I said to this lady, "I have a question to ask you... everybody
who came up to me today was a man. You are the only young woman, and you are young--you weren't born when the movie was made.
What's the story?" She tells me she is crazy about ninja movies, martial arts pictures, and her fiancee is into the same
thing. This was the common subject that they have in common (laughs)! So they fell in love over action movies! And they had
made a vow to name their first two children Joe Armstrong and Curtis Jackson... and they had already put it in the contract
(laughs)! This old movie from 35 years ago has this sort of influence over a young, loving couple only 22 years old.
I would like to once more thank Mr. Firstenberg for being so gracious with his time for this interview. I wish him only
the best in all his future endeavors.
If you missed Part 1 of this interview covering Mr. Firstenberg's early years, and his film work from 1971 to 1984 you can
read it by clicking Here.